Scratching my head
Fr. Longnecker has posted this review of Pope Francis’ speech at Chile’s pontifical university.
It shows just how polarised things are between (in my opinion) those of us who are faithful to the Church and honest about the present situation and those who are sycophants with an agenda. What agenda? Well, some clearly want to change the Church; modernise it.
Some have invested so much time and effort into refuting criticisms of this papacy, to show any crack of acknowledgement at this stage would constitute a totally collapse in credibility:Faggioli belongs to the Bologna School. He literally believes Vatican II was a second Pentecost, that subsequently founded a new religion pic.twitter.com/9AM5d5yw6z— Catholic Sat (@CatholicSat) July 28, 2017
It is Austen Ivereigh who draws Fr. Longnecker's attention in his blog post. He notes that AustenPope cathedral speech a fine example of a spiritual master leading a Church prone to temptations in desolation. #FranciscoEnChile— Austen Ivereigh (@austeni) January 16, 2018
...trumpets that “Pope Francis on Wednesday night gave one of the smartest addresses of his pontificate, one that gives Catholic educational institutions a clear direction for our times.”But has to admit that in reading the article it seemed that if this was one of the Pope’s smartest speeches you really wouldn’t want to read his dumber ones!
Perhaps I am being unfair, and it is difficult to judge a speech in another language simply by a news report, but it strikes me that “how to reflect on what we are feeling and doing; to feel what we are thinking and doing; to do what we are thinking and feeling” just sounds like the sort of gobbledegook we usually hear from an elderly sister in a pantsuit at one of those painful “retreats” where they wear sandals and serve tofu for lunch.
...this is a pope and he’s speaking in a pontifical university. Is there nothing to be said about the Catholic faith, the preaching of the gospel of Jesus Christ, the cultivation of Catholicism and the evangelization of culture? Perhaps it was there, but Ivereigh didn’t fit it into the articleFr. Dwight isn't the only one left scratching his head, both at the strange incoherence of the Pope's ramblings and at Ivereigh's ebullient praise.